1867 Shield Nickel PCGS CAC PR63

The showpiece of our site, this nearly cameo example is approved by CAC as being high-end for the grade. Comparatively, the NO RAYS variety can be found for $1000 with ease. This variety, however, is an extreme rarity. Contact us today to purchase this incredible coin.

1867 Rays Shield Nickel PCGS & CAC PR63
$33000.00

1867 Shield Nickel "Prototype Reverse" NGC PF64 - Reiver

With only an estimated 20 or so examples known, this is likely our highest rarity available. The variety is easily identified by the star and letter positioning. Specifically, the star points between the "TS" in CENTS as opposed to directly at the "T."

1867 no rays Shield 5c PATTERN REVERSE NGC PF64 Reiver
$9995.00

1870 Shield Nickel PCGS PR65

With a nearly cameo obverse, this coin carries a lot of eye appeal. Housed in an older PCGS holder, there's nothing to dislike about this gem proof.

1870 Shield Nickel PCGS PR65
$870.00

1871 Shield Nickel NGC & CAC PF66 CAMEO

Most likely the finest one of the group, this is a supremely choice coin. Spectacular cameo and mark-free, blemish-free fields and devices. Add this CAC approved coin to your collection today!

1871 Shield Nickel NGC & CAC PF66 CAMEO
$1395.00

1871 Shield Nickel PCGS PR64

Beautiful, deep luster covers this pristine coin. The obverse displays a lovely cameo, though the reverse didn't quite make it. Would make a wonderful addition to your collection.

1871 Shield Nickel PCGS PR64
$545.00

1874 Shield Nickel NGC PF64+

Who doesn't love a plus grade? This coin, as with most of our shield nickels, has not been sent to CAC, but there is no doubt it would come back with a green sticker, or perhaps a gold. Lustrous surfaces and tremendous reflective fields. Hurry on this one!

1874 Shield Nickel NGC PF64+
$540.00

1875 Shield Nickel PCGS PR66

Tough date and grade with nice original toning.

1875 Shield Nickel PCGS PR66
$960.00

1875 Shield Nickel NGC PF64

Tougher date and a higher grade.

1875 NGC PF64 Shield Nickel
$495.00

1877 5c Shield Nickel NGC CAC PF65 CAMEO

CAC approved and available for a deeply discounted price!

1877 proof Shield Nickel NGC CAC PF65 CAM
$4000.00

1881 business strike Shield Nickel PCGS VF35

Key dates like this are SO hard to find. Great originality to this old coin!

1881 Shield Nickel PCGS VF35 business strike
$592.00

1881 Shield Nickel NGC PF67

We are likely going to resubmit this one. Totally original and "bowl" mirrors. Looks like a 69, to be honest.

1881 Shield Nickel NGC PF67
$1199.00

1881 Shield Nickel PF66 CAM

High grade and CAM!

1881 Shield Nickel NGC PF66 CAMEO
$725.00

1882 Shield Nickel PCGS PR66 CAMEO

An incredible coin in an older style PCGS holder. This coin has never been to CAC. Part of a new collection consigned to us. Wonderful surfaces and a strong cameo effect.

1882 Shield Nickel PCGS PR66CAM
$1090.00

1882 Shield Nickel NGC PF66

Our highest graded proof, this coin displays a light cameo, and may have qualified if only the "5" digit had retained it's frost. Great value on this high-end coin!

1882 Shield Nickel NGC PF66
$850.00

1883 Shield Nickel NGC PF64

Great flash and minimal marks for a 64.

1883 Shield Nickel NGC PF64
$309.00

1885 Liberty V Nickel PCGS F15

High grade and arguably VF, this great problem-free original is the key to the series and a must have for any serious collector.

1885 V Nickel PCGS F15
$995.00

1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel PCGS G04

A lovely and crusty original. The overdate can clearly be seen with the naked eye. Hurry on this rare date!

1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel PCGS G04
$1125.00

1926-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS VG10

Lovely original - the way a buffalo nickel is supposed to look! This better date coin looks more like a Fine to us.

1926-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS VG10
$81.00

1921-S Buffalo 5c ANACS VF20 LAMINATION ERRORS

Lamination errors are not too hard to find, but they are harder for buffalo nickels and VERY difficult to find on both sides. A great example that we grade VF30.

1921-S Buffalo 5c ANACS Laminations VF20
$350.00